I saw this list of quotes from Stephen King today, and immediately thought "YES!" when I read the first one: "The road to hell is paved with adverbs."
As you know, I give writing advice a lot. I speak from a Bachelors and a Masters in creative writing and (more importantly) as a professional in the publishing industry. I'd like to think I'm pretty qualified to give writing advice, as are many other publishing professionals who offer advice on a regular basis. All we can do is sit back and hope people listen. (Mostly so we don't have to repeat ourselves.)
That said, I understand why some writers don't take our advice.
With so much subjectivity in the field, how does one differentiate between personal taste and unarguable truth? The thing is, there are always going to be exceptions to rules, so nothing is ever set in stone. But! For the most part, especially for a debut author who's way less likely to be able to break any rules, there are some things you'll just need to take an editor's word on.
Bringing me back to adverbs. Poor, poor adverbs. The thing is, they can be used in moderation, but no one ever uses them sparingly enough, so they get ruined for everybody. Adverbs are words that seem to be universally hated by writing professionals, and yet writers continue to use (and abuse) them. It makes me wonder who is listening to writing advice out there.
So I ask you, fair writers:
How often do you listen to writing advice from professionals, either via blogs, conferences, or Twitter?
How many second opinions do you require before you're able to think of suggestions as "rules?"
When something is as frowned upon as adverbs, are you still able to write it off as "personal preference?"
Thanks, friends :)